Barnes on Games- Secrets of the Lost Tomb in Review, Cave Evil Returns, Mission Command: Sea

Barnes on Games- Secrets of the Lost Tomb in Review, Cave Evil Returns, Mission Command: Sea Hot

Michael Barnes     
 
0.0
4220   0
Secrets of the Lost Tomb

Oh, the fonts...


OK, so I've waffled around with Secrets of the Lost Tomb for too long. I kept trying it solo even though my group pretty much laughed it off the table- almost sweeping it into the box unorganized, which is the ultimate doom for a game- and I warmed up to it. Then I cooled on it again. Then I warmed up on it again. But then I realized that it is such a derivative, redundant design with some terrible production qualities that it just does not make a case for itself despite a couple of really good ideas and a neat concept that never really comes to fruition because the content it so scattershot. I hated writing this review because I dislike coming down on a designer's first game and all that, but honesty is honesty and I promised an honest review of it. I kind of felt like this game might have that kind of crazy-enough-to-work approach, but it's almost embarrassingly close to the Launius/Wilson/Coniescka Lovecraft games AND Betrayal at the House on the Hill. So the review is here at No High Scores- it's rare for me to do a negative one, but here it is.

I drank whiskey last night and soloed Cave Evil with two Necromancers in light of the recent announcement that Warcults preorders are open. I had not played it in some time, it was good to get it back out. Loved it just as much as I always have. Murder Giant for the win.  It's an interesting design because it is really pretty old fashioned- one of those games that feels like it fell out of a time warp. I think it's very much a modern Titan, but it adds some cool stuff like the tunneling, the resource management, spells and equipment. Fans of that kind of design, circa 1982 or so, really need to be looking at Cave Evil. Interested in seeing where Warcults takes it.

I did a little trade for Mission Command: Sea of all things, a game that you used to be able to buy by the case for $4.99 a piece. What a neat little game- I know it's just Carrier Strike, but there are some cool updates. I tried it with River and he mostly understood it, but some things like the differences between Harpoons and Sidewinders were a little confusing. I really like how simple and direct it is, I like how the "to hit" numbers are based on range. I think I might get the Air one next. I used to have Tank Battle, which is the basis for the land one, but I remember not really liking it much.

 

 

 

 

Barnes on Games- Secrets of the Lost Tomb in Review, Cave Evil Returns, Mission Command: Sea There Will Be Games
Log in to comment
Posted: 15 Oct 2015 15:17 by SuperflyTNT #212519
SuperflyTNT's Avatar
Mission Command: Sea is one of my all time favorite games.

superflycircus.blogspot.com/2013/05/miss...mc-detection-on.html

I absolutely adore it. The AIR game sucks. Great toy factor but the game itself isn't much fun. The LAND version isn't much better, but is slightly better than AIR. YMMV
Posted: 15 Oct 2015 16:02 by JonJacob #212523
OldHippy's Avatar
To think people are arguing about the aesthetic of Cave Evil... my God look at Secret of the Lost Tomb... that is one of the ugliest boxes I've ever seen.
Posted: 15 Oct 2015 22:32 by Tim Champlin #212547
Tim Champlin's Avatar
Still waiting for that great Indiana Jones style game. I've been thinking about getting Fortune and Glory, but still not sure.
Posted: 15 Oct 2015 23:38 by Grudunza #212550
Grudunza's Avatar
Fortune and Glory ain't "that great Indiana Jones style game." The Adventurers is lighter than I would hope for a real IJ game, but it is a good game, at least.

Indiana Jones 5 is still likely to happen (Spielberg mentioned it the other day), and Disney will likely reboot it after Ford retires/dies... So I'm hoping the great game in that license may yet come. #galeforcenine
Posted: 16 Oct 2015 00:52 by Hex Sinister #212552
Hex Sinister's Avatar
I have heard absolutely nothing positive about Fortune and Glory. Be wary.
Posted: 16 Oct 2015 06:39 by Legomancer #212559
Legomancer's Avatar
Oh god, the first two words of the SotLT review.

"Everything Epic" is the name of the publisher. I know I'm a joyless crank, but this game would have to be farting previously unreleased Ultra Vivid Scene tracks for me to not put it back on the shelf at that sight.
Posted: 16 Oct 2015 07:05 by SuperflyTNT #212563
SuperflyTNT's Avatar
Grudunza wrote:
Fortune and Glory ain't "that great Indiana Jones style game." The Adventurers is lighter than I would hope for a real IJ game, but it is a good game, at least.

Indiana Jones 5 is still likely to happen (Spielberg mentioned it the other day), and Disney will likely reboot it after Ford retires/dies... So I'm hoping the great game in that license may yet come. #galeforcenine

I really think that Temple of Chac is the real deal Indiana Jonesing game.
Posted: 16 Oct 2015 07:28 by charlest #212564
charlest's Avatar
Escape: Curse of the Temple is also a stupid fun game with a bit of Temple of Doom flair.
Posted: 16 Oct 2015 07:44 by SuperflyTNT #212568
SuperflyTNT's Avatar
It's not as stupid as I first thought. Yes, there's basically a rolling mechanic and that's about it, but the decisions about how to work together and pushing your luck are huge.
Posted: 16 Oct 2015 07:56 by charlest #212569
charlest's Avatar
Yes, and I'm a big fan of the expansions and how seamless you can tune the difficult for your group (we ride with every expansion and 2 extra gems).
Posted: 16 Oct 2015 11:45 by waddball #212590
waddball's Avatar
The Mission Command games are fun for kids. I only played the Land one (reimplements Tank Battle, which I played a lot as a youth). Good nostalgic fun.