Heroes of Black Reach Review

MB Updated
Heroes of Black Reach Review

All the dakka, none of the plastic.

As much as I like Devil Pig's Heroes of Normandie and Shadows over Normandie lines (brought to the US by iEllo), there is always a somewhat tentative relationship with these highly cinematic, tactical scale wargame designs. Because of some rather shaky rules writing, enough icons to fill a book of rebuses, and a ton of detail compressed into multiple micro-systems, it's one of those designs where you wind up nose-deep in the rulebook for most of the game and when it ends you face a number of lingering questions - including "did we really play that right?" And then there are the mountains of recruitment options, support tiles, terrain overlays, expansion content, scenarios, and other content to contend with once you have what you think is a decent grasp on how to play. Regardless, I enjoyed both games quite a lot and the announcement that the French company had been granted the Warhammer 40k license to do a new title, Heroes of Black Reach, was one I met with celebration.

And lo, Heroes of Black Reach is another Yann and Clem game through and through. The rulebook still sucks, arranged in nightmare logic and it always seems to leave one with more questions than answers. Most of the game is more or less a reskin with some evolution from the more fantasy-inflected Shadows to accommodate the Psykers and powers of the 40k setting. And the good news is that it really works, with the World War II era tactics and concepts porting over a few millennia into the future without missing a beat.

Interestingly, it sort of sets the dial back in the 40k world to the conflict between the Ultramarines chapter of the Space Marines and the Orks at Black Reach, which was the subject of the fifth edition 40k starter set over a decade ago. And the units depicted here are from that era as well- so no Primaris or anything more recent. And, quite interestingly, the game may satisfy those who feel that 8th edition 40k has gotten too accessible or casual- because it is really a considerably more complex game than the current edition of the popular miniatures rules.

There is a small-ish campaign that you can play through with some pre-set terrain maps and forces, but like most of Devil Pig's scenarios, it's not really all that great. In fact, it feels like a step down from the campaign in Shadows. The "roll your own" scenarios tend to produce the more interesting games, with players setting up based on a couple of parameters and the nifty tile-based army building mechanisms that have been with the design from the beginning. Each unit tile indicates which counters it gets by default and they have one or more upgrade slots that you can spend points to fill with things like ammo, heavy weapons, or other wargear. And then you can stick on matching support tiles- things like Razorbacks, Dreadnaughts, Killa Kans, and other fun things. A 300 point match up across four terrain tiles is worth about an hour's play time- it would be roughly equivalent to a 750-1000 point 40k game.

Once you've managed to sort out the rules and get it set up, the gameplay is great. Activations are handled through a very Heroscape-like mechanism, with each player getting a number of activation counters per the number of stars on their recruitment tiles. These are placed in secret and go off in order with the possibility for some bluffing. Units can move OR shoot when activated, unless they have a "Fire on the Move" icon. Every unit is color-coded by its type, and all units get a +X bonus against each type. The shooting roll is just a D6, add modifiers, hits if you roll over the target's armor. But that's not the half of it, because with some weapons you can also choose to shoot to suppress. And there are terrain matters to consider, including firing over intervening terrain or into cover. Then there are the action cards that each side has to play with, which can cause all kinds of crazy things to happen.

But if you can't bolter down a group of Sluggas before they can run up on you, there is also assault combat, which requires a contested roll. If you are shooting at a heavy vehicle- like, say, a Land Raider or a Deff Dread- only certain units can even affect them. Those that can will inflict specific damage such as disabling mobility or weapons until they are destroyed and leave a flaming wreck that you can use for cover. There are also flamers, grenades, Camo Cloaks, ambushing Scouts, indirect fire, vehicle facing, and transport to consider. And we haven't even gotten into air support or the Psyker powers yet. It's all a bit of a mess, but erring on the side of MORE seems to pay off well with these games.

So the point is here that there is a TON of content to dig into here, and there is quite a lot of detail. We aren't at ASL levels here, but interested parties should be advised that this is not a light skirmish game- it's several steps over Memoir '44 and closer to Combat Commander in terms of complexity. With that said, I would strongly advise that anyone that wants to check this game out do so with the understanding that the learning curve is sharp and it would behoove you to have at least one other person around that is equally interested in getting stuck in with the system. It is very rewarding and exciting once it comes together, with some really fun and detailed over-the-top wargame action. Oddly, I would recommend it to fans of Earth Reborn as much or possibly more than I would to Warhammer players. The Heroes System games have some shared DNA with Boelinger's bizarro magnum opus.

In my most recent game, I set up a friend with a Space Marine Tactical squad with a Plasma gun option and a Predator. I took a mob of Boyz, a Warbuggy, and a Deff Dread. And it totally felt like a full-on 40k game but with maybe a little more detail than that system really affords. The Predator rolled out, laying down suppressing fire on my Boyz and pretty much just erasing the Warbuggy out of the starting gate. It whiffed on damaging the Deff Dread, which assaulted the tank. Basically, it ran up and started punching it. Plasma was toasting the wall of Orks left and right before succumbing to a Slugga assault, so the Astartes Sergeant made a hail mary to reach the objective I set up- but was stopped in his tracks by the Ork Boss who gave him what-for with his Power Klaw. The Marines managed to take the objective by pushing hard against the Green Tide by taking advantage of some great cards and squeezed out a win on the last turn.

Like the previous games, the focus is on vivid, hero-scaled action as demonstrated above. I was concerned that the game, hewing so close to the previous designs, wouldn't feel like 40k. In fact, I believe that you could actually play Normandie armies in Black Reach if you really wanted to see how the US Army would fare against a Goff Ork mob. But it does feel like 40k in a satisfying way, and I'm hoping this iteration expands into other factions. I'd love to see an Tau or Necron army take to the field here. I'm not sure it is a valid substitute for the miniatures game, but as a more traditional chit-based Warhammer game it is really quite successful despite reservations about accessibility and the quality of the rules presentation.

Thank you to iEllo for supplying a review copy of this game and for supporting quality games writing. ThereWillBe.Games does not accept any payment or editorial direction from publishers or designers.

Have you seen my Patreon? It's here - http://www.patreon.com/michaelbarnes. Pitch in a buck and I'll enter you to win a review copy every month!

 

There Will Be Games Heroes of Black Reach Review

Shop Amazon - When you make a purchase using these links a small % goes to the support of this site


Heroes of Black Reach Review Michael BarnesFollow Michael Barnes Follow Michael Barnes Message Michael Barnes

Editor-in-Chief

Sometime in the early 1980s, MichaelBarnes’ parents thought it would be a good idea to buy him a board game to keep him busy with some friends during one of those high-pressure, “free” timeshare vacations. It turned out to be a terrible idea, because the game was TSR’s Dungeon! - and the rest, as they say, is history. Michael has been involved with writing professionally about games since 2002, when he busked for store credit writing for Boulder Games’ newsletter. He has written for a number of international hobby gaming periodicals and popular Web sites. From 2004-2008, he was the co-owner of Atlanta Game Factory, a brick-and-mortar retail store. He is currently the co-founder of FortressAT.com and Nohighscores.com as well as the Editor-in-Chief of Miniature Market’s Review Corner feature. He is married with two childen and when he’s not playing some kind of game he enjoys stockpiling trivial information about music, comics and film. 

Editor rating

1 reviews

Board Game Reviews 
 
4.0

Summary

Heroes of Black Reach
A sometimes bewildering, sometimes awesome tactical scale cardboard take on 40k.
MB
Log in to comment

Gary Sax's Avatar
Gary Sax replied the topic: #289192 03 Jan 2019 13:21
Been looking forward to this review, thanks!
Gary Sax's Avatar
Gary Sax replied the topic: #289211 03 Jan 2019 17:06
btw, did you get the two initial space marine and ork expansions? Are they worth it?

They're definitely leaning into the miniatures product line thing, which I think makes some sense theoretically since they're going 40k.
Michael Barnes's Avatar
Michael Barnes replied the topic: #289212 03 Jan 2019 17:13
I actually just ordered them...they add quite a lot of options and more variety...like Nobz and Terminators. There’s probably twice as many units on the flats, and that means a lot more flexibility in scenarios. But I think there is plenty in the main box for most folks to explore for a while, I really just wanted the add ons to have more “complete” army options.
Gary Sax's Avatar
Gary Sax replied the topic: #289275 05 Jan 2019 11:39
Oh yeah, terminators would be a key addition for SM.

Final question, did your printing quality look ok? I guess this company is on its last legs financially and there was a little talk on BGG about how dark printing was: www.boardgamegeek.com/thread/2088637/dark-printing
Michael Barnes's Avatar
Michael Barnes replied the topic: #289276 05 Jan 2019 12:04
Oh FFS, that reference picture dude posted is a CG render. If he expected the printing to look as crisp and bright on linen finish cardboard...Christ.

Everything looks fine to me...it didn’t even cross my mind that it was too dark or muddy.

I’ve heard varying accounts of Devil Pig’s pending demise...apparently there is a Heroes of Eagle Gate box coming later this year- that’s Imperial Fists versus Word Bearers. And they say there are plans for more but who knows. HOBR is put out by iEllo here in the US, maybe they’ll buy them out or something.
Hadik's Avatar
Hadik replied the topic: #289301 06 Jan 2019 08:34
As usual, I like your review but my wallet hates it.
fightcitymayor's Avatar
fightcitymayor replied the topic: #289677 09 Jan 2019 15:30

Michael Barnes wrote: Because of some rather shaky rules writing, enough icons to fill a book of rebuses, and a ton of detail compressed into multiple micro-systems, it's one of those designs where you wind up nose-deep in the rulebook for most of the game and when it ends you face a number of lingering questions - including "did we really play that right?" And then there are the mountains of recruitment options, support tiles, terrain overlays, expansion content, scenarios, and other content to contend with once you have what you think is a decent grasp on how to play.

I'm pleased someone has brought this up, I've always felt bad for people who see the cartoony box art and think "Yeah, a quick-playing intro game!" and then have to read multiple awful rulebooks and memorize 30,000 different icons and corner-case rules exceptions.

And also: It's ironic that Devil Pig deciding to make this game is playing a big part in possibly driving them out of business. But supposedly the "Heroes Of" systems are safe for now, they have sold off or shuttered their other games though.