• Rants & Raves
  • Flashback Friday - Cartagena - Love It or Hate It? Do You Still Play It?

Flashback Friday - Cartagena - Love It or Hate It? Do You Still Play It?

U Updated
Cartagena board game

Game Information

Game Name
Designer
Follow Us
 
There Will Be Games

This pirate themed racing game was once the go-to filler game at every game day.

Designed by Leo Colovini, and published in 2000, it was a Spiel des Jahres Recommendation in 2001. Cartagena's theme is the 1672 pirate-led jailbreak from the dreaded fortress of Cartagena. It came with a little story about it, so you got a little history lesson with the your game. It also included two variations,  Jamaica and Tortuga, which play really quite differntly from each other

In 2006 a sequel - Cartagena II was released.

The current Cartagena 2nd edition, released in 2017, includes the original game, the sequel includes, and several variants including a "black magic varient".

Is this game still on your shelf? Which version do you prefer? Love it or hate it? Do you still play it? 

There Will Be Games Cartagena board game

Cartagena board game
Shellie "ubarose" Rose  (She/Her)
Managing Editor & Web Admin

Plays boardgames. Drinks bourbon. Writes code.

Articles by Shellie

Cartagena board game
Shellie "ubarose" Rose
Managing Editor & Web Admin

Articles by Shellie

Log in to comment

mc's Avatar
mc replied the topic: #292886 22 Feb 2019 03:21
I bought the new edition for my daughter last year after she played it with me at a con and said she really wished we had it at home.

I like Colovini's stuff that I've played- it's really bare essence kind of thing, you know, fully distilled. Really simple games, but there's always something interesting there. Explain in 2 minutes, start playing, and then get kind of engrossed in it as you realise there's obviously got to be a bit of a trick to doing well, but, you can't quite see it, or it's going to depend on what the other players are doing. This one, you've got to have a keen eye for timing things right, or you just get stranded. And if you think about it, what he's done here is basically make Candyland into a real game with a minor tweak. It's a neat little engineering solution if nothing else.

The new edition is kind of like choose your own game - there's all sorts of variables - I think you can play Cartagena, Cartagena 2, a combination of bits of those, where you have to get on a boat but there are limited spots, a version where you play it backwards (as in, you pull the pirates forward to pick up cards (i think) ) and it also has these extra rules which give each suit a special ability. They work pretty well and give it a bit of spice. Basically you have to declare you are using the special ability with a card instead of using it for movement. They are also vaguely thematic (at least in comparison with the main game). So like, if you use the gun symbol special ability you get to rob an opponent of a card. There are treasures to go on the treasure spaces that you can dig up (extra cards, mainly, but also a snake that bites you and you have to go back to the last available rum spot for a drink to calm your nerves). So they're kind of fun, and whenever we play the game we pretty much always use that ruleset.

Something else to point out as that the publisher (or Colovini, I don't know) kind of Fargo'd the whole "famous jailbreak" thing - nothing like it ever happened, as far as I've been able to make out.
stormseeker75's Avatar
stormseeker75 replied the topic: #293036 26 Feb 2019 07:28
Cartagena is perfect. So simple to teach and tons of player interaction. I don't play this much because I don't have groups around, but I will play this any time someone asks to play it.
ubarose's Avatar
ubarose replied the topic: #293041 26 Feb 2019 09:14
I am a bit surprised at how few responses we have to this weeks FBF. Perhaps this is a indication that Cartagena didn’t have the staying power of some of the other games that we have featured.
Jackwraith's Avatar
Jackwraith replied the topic: #293042 26 Feb 2019 09:43
Yeah, sorry. There's a rather large chunk of German/Euro-style games that I have virtually no connection to whatsoever and this is one of them. During the years that those were coming to prominence, I was largely out of the board game scene, so I've never played or only played a lot of classics like El Grande or Cartegena a couple times. I have since caught up on a lot of Knizia designs and played them extensively, but not much more. Give me a Games Workshop or Avalon Hill or SPI or Knizia Flashback and I'm all over it. But I'm a little limited on mid- to late-90s Euros.
ubarose's Avatar
ubarose replied the topic: #293047 26 Feb 2019 10:21
No need to be sorry. It is interesting to discover what games that were popular when they first came out, and have been around and in print (more or less) for 10-20 years have been able to find new audiences, and which ones haven’t.

I wonder if part of the problem is they didn’t stay true to the clean simplicity of the original game, and muddied it up with all the variants they added in.
san il defanso's Avatar
san il defanso replied the topic: #293083 26 Feb 2019 15:49
I ended up reviewing this for MM and I found it pretty thin. Lots of great light German games from the turning of the millennium, but this one frankly lighter than I cared for.
Colorcrayons's Avatar
Colorcrayons replied the topic: #293106 27 Feb 2019 10:25

ubarose wrote: I am a bit surprised at how few responses we have to this weeks FBF. Perhaps this is a indication that Cartagena didn’t have the staying power of some of the other games that we have featured.


I've never even heard if it until now.

Literally.

No recommendations, no whispers about it while playing Jamaica/Pirates of the Spanish Main/etc.

Nothing.

I don't think of myself as insular when it comes to games, and like to think of myself as fairly well informed, moreso than even many informed users at ToS.